Black Lives Matter Protests – a personal perspective

It still seems quite murky to me as to why these protests are taking place in the UK. It was my understanding that the UK retained particularly strong race relations across it’s ethnic minority groups. On top of this, with Covid-19 lock-down in effect, it should be in people’s best interests to follow government rules and remain socially distant. However, according to the protesters, Covid-19 could wait because there was another pandemic, one of racism.

The flashpoint to all of this is obvious. The murder of George Flloyd by a Minneapolis Police Department officer, while on looked by three of his colleagues marks the beginnings of the protests and the violence taking place across the US and UK. Since this abhorrent incident took place, it has led the racial equality movement Black Lives Matter to draw parallels between the overt racist incidents that take place in the US, and more subtle and far less numerous incidents that have taken place in the UK  (for a different interpretion of George Floyd’s death see Candice Owens below).

I personally think the UK has come a long way from its colonial past. Figures such as William Wilberforce and the Quakers were instrumental in the abolition of the slave trade. During the Second World War, black soldiers with the US military felt safer and more accepted here in the UK than they did at home. In 1965, the Race Relations act was passed making discriminations based on colour, race or ethnic background illegal in public places in Great Britain. In 1968, the act was strengthened to cover employment and housing. It was repealed by the ‘Race Relations Act of 1976’ which brought about the creation of the Commission for Racial Equality. Racial tensions between the various ethnic minorities have boiled over throughout the 70s and 80s, but systematically speaking the racist legislation was eliminated by this point.

However, the recent Windrush scandal, and tragic Grenfell Tower fire and aftermath have given momentum to the Black Lives Matter movement as both of these neglectful incidents have led to disproportionate effects on ethnic minorities, leading BLM members to believe that the UK is systematically racist, through neglectful policy making. On top of this, crime statistics have been rolled out stating that black people are more likely to be arrested than other ethnicities.

The George Flloyd incident appears, to me at least, to be an opportunity for the BLM movement to point out racial injustice in the UK at a time when the topic is currently poignant.

What it’s been like living in Newbury

I’m not black myself, but mixed race. There are some people who don’t make that distinction but others (myself included) do, which may potentially cause polarisation, so make of that what you will. My father is African American, and has since returned to the US, meaning my white English mother raised me. Due to this, culturally I’m more white than I am black. I’ve grown up around white faces with very few people of colour.

I’ve lived in Newbury my entire life, except for the four years I spent at university in Hull. For the entire time I’ve lived here I’ve noticed very few faces of colour, though that trend has been changing more recently. But the lack of coloured faces is not something I’d consider problematic. It’s just the way Newbury has been. Generally speaking, this is a strongly middle class area with fewer less-skilled work opportunities. Subsequently it doesn’t attract many people of any ethnicity to construct a new life here. There are more commonly opportunities of that kind in the larger cities and that’s where the majority of migrants congregate.

However, this has not negatively affected my personal experiences in Newbury. Excluding the occasional comment based in ignorance such as being called ‘half-caste’ rather than mixed race, or being asked where I’m from ‘originally’, due to my ‘exotic’ name and complexion, I’ve not experienced any aggravated racism. The ignorant comments and questions I have received have not been taken to heart, because my reading of them wasn’t contextually negative, but just curious. Unfortunately my partner of full African heritage has in her time here, as did my father when he was here, so I don’t believe it is completely non-existent. There are still unfortunate instances of normalised racial slurs in common usage such as ‘paki-shop’ and ‘chinky takeaway’. In my own experiences though, these are used by older people and my generation tend to avoid these.

Who is instigating the protests?

The protests in Newbury were organised by 16 year-old friends Sam Morton and Livia Popplewell from the local area with support from the Black Lives Matter movement and the local council. They stated that they felt the protests in Reading and London were too far away to reasonably attend with lock-down in effect and that it is important that a small town like Newbury should have the opportunity to show solidarity with the wider movement protesting the murder of George Flloyd.

This is where the issue gets a controversial. The Black Lives Matter movement is more than just a racial justice movement. On it’s website, it mentions a number of political issues irrelevant to racial justice: it is in fact a far-left neo-Marxist group. This is partially why I was conflicted about attendance. I disagree with neo-Marxism and find it distasteful for this group to politicise the death of George Flloyd. I’ve read George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four and feel it dangerous to begin erasing national histories. With the attacks on statues taking place across the UK, a concerning precedent is being set about how to treat British history.

Certain statues, such as the infamous Edward Coulson statue in Bristol, in my opinion could be relocated to a museum, where anyone interested could learn much more about the exploits of the man, both positive and negative. I don’t however, condone the vandalism, and believe the utmost respect should be adhered to when dealing with such issues.

Why was I going?

I decided in the end that I wanted to attend in order to protest for police reform in the US and reform of institutional and cultural racism here in the UK – without supporting the political leanings of BLM.

I felt an urge to stand in solidarity against police brutality that has taken place for too long in the United States. I fear a scenario where my father experiences a similar injustice. With regard to Newbury, I’m proud to have been part of the protest and of Newbury in general. The local council was very supportive of the protest which took place without issue. There would appear to be very little room left for bigoted views in the UK, and it’ll take time for the remnants of those views to disappear. Similarly, I don’t see need for sweeping political change in the UK. Policy implementation with a thought given to residing minorities is a must. But in my opinion the UK in not in a bad place as progress long as steady and continuous.

How did it go?

The organisers were expecting fewer than 50 people, but come the time, Newbury came out in force at an estimated 500 people mostly, but not all, young. Plenty of thought was given to social distancing too, with almost everyone wearing masks and trying their best to maintain a distance from each other. The crowd marched down Northbrook street towards the Town Hall, chanting and waving signs. As we passed the First World War memorial at St Nicholas’ church, police and a handful counter protesters had gathered to protect the memorial, but in this instance there was no interest in it.

The march continued on in to the market where the crowd rallied to listen to the speakers. I found it difficult to hear the speeches, but a friend I attended the rally with said that listening to the first hand accounts of being bullied and frightened helped her to understand better the privilege of not experiencing these hardships and barriers herself. The event ended with the crowd taking a knee for a two minute silence in memory of George Flloyd, before the protestors peacefully dispersed.

Conclusion

I think the protest has drawn a lot of attention to the cause of tackling racism. The local council and police were supportive of the protest and there was little counter to it. However, I think it’s effectiveness in tangible action is very difficult to measure. With the backdrop of the Covid-19 pandemic requiring us all to return to our homes, with limited connectivity with the outside world, this could easily have been an opportunity for many to signal virtue without any intention to take action.

Prolific black conservative Candice Owens posted a video online stating that George Flloyd should not be viewed as a martyr for his tragic death. He died committing a crime, and while he definitely should not have died in police custody, he also should not have committed the crime. I’m in agreement with this perspective. He had a history of criminal activity and at the time of his arrest was caught in possession of drugs and acting suspiciously. However, neither Candice nor I see this as a valid excuse for the actions of the police officer.

She goes on to state however that racial discrimination in policing in the US is a myth, and my interpretation of what happens leads me to agree to an extent. In both the UK and the US, statistics show that black people commit more crime than other ethnic groups. I therefore believe that what may be called racism by the BLM movement and the media may actually be another instance of these policies unintentionally and disproportionally effecting black communities with no deliberate racism taking place.

Similarly, in the case of the US, the job is exceedingly tough, and the police force rally around their own, often resulting in officers not being held to account for their actions. I therefore believe that both sides should take away a lesson from this incident. I believe certain elements of the black community may need to look within to address those that commit crimes. I also think that police and policy makers must also look within to better address policy written in ignorance.

Andre Anthony

Click here for the Penny Post video of the protest in Newbury on Friday 12 June 2020

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on email
Email
Share on print
Print

2 Responses

  1. First I must aay I am glad to see a post on this issue and commend you for sharing. I am not one to usually respond on these things but felt a duty to revert here as I think this article is extraordinarily one sided and somewhat dangerous.

    It is ok to say you have never experienced racism … it is not ok to then assume that on that basis racism is not an issue in this country. I have never been raped … but that would never be a basis for me to undermine others experience. I have never been sexually harassed in the work place nor have i ever seen it but again that is not a basis to undermine the me too movement. Some of what is in this article reminds me of the “well those girls were wearing short skirts … or they were in the wrong place ” etc I hate to be graphic here but thats how it feels.

    If the writers personal experience does not allow him to understand whats going on it would be helpful if he engaged with those that are expressing pain here in the UK

    Lets put police brutality aside … institutional racism is a reality. I went to one of the top universitirs in this country where from my peers professors alike i experience racism in various forms and degrees.

    I am glad that the author has not experienced racism in his life but feel thathis conclusion and rhetoric is one sided and insensitive.

    I am a black woman a professional who grew up in Newbury and now work in London. I have been a victim of racism both explicit and instiutionally my whole life. When I read this article I felt like my experiences were being undermined.

    Whilst I may not necessarily agree with every aspect of the BLM to say that there is no issue simply because one has not had a personal experience is rather ignorant.

    To say … black people commit more crime … without consideration of the history and the other more nuanced socioeconomic aspects is dangerous. Regardless of whether or not someone had a history of crime murder is murder and when the same keeps happening to people some qho arent criminals … we have to stop and consider why. Also point to note when we look at the US a lot of the
    Men that have been killed were not criminals.

    The reason black people in the UK are joining are varied and cannot be simplified but to touch on a couple 1 solidarity and 2 most including might I had people like Leona Lewis for what its worth of us have had to confront things that have happened to us on a personal level that we have pushed to the back of our minds in order to not offend people. I for one have years of experience with racism that I have never spoken about and in the late weeks that has all come to the surface.

    I hope that this publication would reach out to someone who may sit on the other side of this fence for their story.

    It is a privilege to live life without an experience of racism and it is irresponsible to disregard the experiences of others just because you have had that privilege.

    1. Firstly, I’d like to say thank you for your comment. Obviously this is just my perspective, but yourself and others have taken the time to help me better understand what others have and are experiencing.

      “It is ok to say you have never experienced racism … it is not ok to then assume that on that basis racism is not an issue in this country.”

      You’re absolutely right, and I agree that I was ignorant on the experiences of others. However, I would like to point out that I didn’t state in the article, and don’t believe that racism isn’t an issue at all.

      “Unfortunately my partner of full African heritage has in her time here, as did my father when he was here, so I don’t believe it is completely non-existent.”

      I’m still learning a lot about this issue, and the feedback I’ve received from yourself, my partner and a number of my friends has helped me to understand certain things that I didn’t previously. In intend to write a follow-up based on this feedback, to highlight where there are still issues that should be addressed.

      “To say … black people commit more crime … without consideration of the history and the other more nuanced socioeconomic aspects is dangerous. Regardless of whether or not someone had a history of crime murder is murder and when the same keeps happening to people some who aren’t criminals … we have to stop and consider why. Also point to note when we look at the US a lot of the
      Men that have been killed were not criminals.”

      Again, you’re completely right and I didn’t cover the socio economic aspects in great enough detail. I’m very much aware that the situation is far more complicated than I managed to convey in the article.

      Again, thank you for your comment. I really appreciate the time you’ve taken to help me understand this topic from a different perspective. As I said, I’m working on a follow up piece that hopefully can go some way towards addressing aspects that I failed to with this piece.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Coverage Area

What's On

Jul
8
Wed
2020
7:00 am Hungerford Wednesday Market @ Hungerford High Street
Hungerford Wednesday Market @ Hungerford High Street
Jul 8 @ 7:00 am – 2:30 pm
Hungerford Wednesday Market @ Hungerford High Street | England | United Kingdom
Wednesday is market day in Hungerford, when cars give way to shoppers, traders and stalls filled with fresh fruit, vegetable, fish, meat, flowers, plants, clothes,
Jul
9
Thu
2020
9:00 am Newbury Thursday and Saturday Ma... @ Newbury (Northbrook Street, Market Place)
Newbury Thursday and Saturday Ma... @ Newbury (Northbrook Street, Market Place)
Jul 9 @ 9:00 am – 4:00 pm
Newbury Thursday and Saturday Market @ Newbury (Northbrook Street, Market Place) | Newbury | England | United Kingdom
Newbury Market is a bustling one-stop shop for all your essentials. The majority of the traders have been on the market for many years so
7:00 pm Quiz Night With Wiltshire Libraries @ Online - Facebook
Quiz Night With Wiltshire Libraries @ Online - Facebook
Jul 9 @ 7:00 pm – 8:00 pm
Quiz Night With Wiltshire Libraries @ Online - Facebook
Following the success of our Quiz Night for World Book Night join us every Thursday for a one round quiz (not necessarily about literature!) Questions
Jul
10
Fri
2020
8:00 am Lambourn Friday Market @ Lambourn Market Square
Lambourn Friday Market @ Lambourn Market Square
Jul 10 @ 8:00 am – 4:00 pm
Lambourn Friday Market @ Lambourn Market Square | Lambourn | England | United Kingdom
Come and browse Lambourne’s market stalls. Our range spans from Fresh Produce, to a Butchers and other essential foods and items.
Jul
11
Sat
2020
9:00 am Newbury Thursday and Saturday Ma... @ Newbury (Northbrook Street, Market Place)
Newbury Thursday and Saturday Ma... @ Newbury (Northbrook Street, Market Place)
Jul 11 @ 9:00 am – 4:00 pm
Newbury Thursday and Saturday Market @ Newbury (Northbrook Street, Market Place) | Newbury | England | United Kingdom
Newbury Market is a bustling one-stop shop for all your essentials. The majority of the traders have been on the market for many years so

Sign up to the free weekly

Penny Post

e-newsletter 

for local, positive news, events, jobs, recipes, recommendations & more.

Covering: Hungerford, Marlborough, Wantage,   Lambourn, Newbury, Thatcham & Theale